Some furnaces tell you they are near the end
The clearest sign is a cracked heat exchanger. It can let combustion gases, including carbon monoxide, into the air the blower sends through the house, and it is the one fault a technician should not leave running. If we find one, we shut the furnace off and give you a written replacement price. The Ontario Fire Code requires a working carbon monoxide alarm next to each sleeping area of a home with a fuel-burning appliance, so check yours while you wait.
Other signs build up slowly. You might be on your third repair call in two winters. The blower might get louder each season. An older mid-efficiency furnace might still vent into a masonry chimney. Or the back bedroom upstairs stays a few degrees colder than the kitchen wherever the thermostat is set. None of this means the furnace has to go tomorrow. Taken together, though, these signs mean it's worth getting a replacement price before the next cold snap rather than in the middle of it.
Repair or replace is your call, with both numbers on paper
If the furnace is fairly young and the fault is a part such as an igniter, inducer motor or control board, repairing it usually makes sense. If the furnace is old and the repair is a big one, the money often goes further on a new unit. You get both prices in writing and you decide. Our guide on what decides the cost of a furnace repair or a new furnace explains what moves the number.
Homeowners on a low to moderate income can look into the County of Simcoe's home repair funding, which covers urgent repairs. Applications are taken all year, but funding is limited and there can be a waitlist, so it's better to apply early than in the middle of a breakdown.
A new furnace is sized to the house, not to the old label
The furnace in the basement may have been oversized when it went in, or the house may have changed since then: new windows, more attic insulation, a finished basement or an addition. Copying the old rating carries those mistakes forward. An oversized furnace heats in short bursts, swings between hot and cold, and wears out its parts early. One that is too small runs flat out on the coldest nights and still falls behind.
So we measure the house: walls, windows, insulation, air leakage and the ducts. That gives a heat loss figure and, for a house that has central air or will get it, a heat gain figure too. The Township of Essa requires a building permit to renovate a structure, and its application checklist asks for HVAC details, including heat loss and gain calculations and layout where applicable. The same figures serve both purposes.
Sizing matters more here than in a milder place. Environment Canada's 1991 to 2020 normals for Egbert show 4,278.8 degree days below 18 °C and a record low of −35.5 °C on January 16, 1994. A furnace runs for a lot of hours in a heating season that long, and a well-matched one runs them quietly and evenly.
Older houses often need the ducts, venting or chimney reworked
A farmhouse or village house from before 1945 was built for wood or coal heat. That includes houses in the old core of Thornton, in Ivy and in Utopia. Most were converted to oil and later to gas, and the ductwork was added after the house was built. That's why the upstairs rooms get weak airflow: the duct runs are long, the returns are few, and the ducts were squeezed into a house that was never planned for them. A new furnace won't fix that on its own. Sometimes adding a return or two and rebalancing the air does more for the cold bedroom than a bigger unit would.
Venting is the other question. A high-efficiency furnace vents through the side wall in plastic pipe. That can leave a gas water heater venting alone into an old masonry chimney sized for a much bigger fire. On its own, the water heater may not draw properly up the chimney, and the chimney usually needs a liner. We tell you this before we write the price.
The married quarters around Arras Road at CFB Borden were built in the 1940s and 50s for an oil or early gas furnace vented into a chimney. They have small ducts and were never planned for air conditioning. A modern furnace, especially one paired with central air, often runs into ductwork that is too small and venting that has to be redone. That work is included in the quote.
Side-wall pipes go where the snow will not bury them
Most houses built in Angus, Thornton and Baxter since the 1990s already have a condensing furnace vented through the side wall, and the replacement will be vented the same way. Egbert's normals show 174.1 cm of snow a year, falling on about 57 days. A drift or a plow ridge over the intake and exhaust pipes is a common reason these furnaces shut themselves off in a storm. When we replace the furnace, we place the pipes with that in mind: height above the usual snow line, distance from the deck and the driveway, and clearance from windows and the gas meter.
The condensate line gets the same attention. A condensing furnace makes water, and it will shut down if the drain sags, runs through a cold corner or empties into a line that freezes. The venting guide explains what to check after a storm.
How the installation is done
A technician visits, measures the house, looks at the ducts, the venting and the chimney, and asks how the rooms actually feel in January. You get a written price that covers the furnace, any duct, venting or liner work, and the permit. Nothing is fitted until you approve it.
Work is performed by TSSA-certified gas technicians. In Ontario, gas furnaces are installed to the CSA B149.1 Natural Gas and Propane Installation Code, adopted under Ontario Regulation 212/01. We disconnect and remove the old furnace, then set, pipe, vent and wire the new one. Then we start it and test the gas pressure, the combustion, the temperature rise across the heat exchanger, the condensate flow and the thermostat.
Before the technician leaves, they show you the filter, the vent pipes outside and the condensate drain. Register the furnace with the manufacturer and keep the installation and service records. Manufacturers often ask for proof of regular maintenance before they honour a warranty claim, and a yearly tune-up gives you that record. If you're weighing a cold-climate heat pump with the gas furnace as backup, ask for that price at the same visit.
